Deep Time · Side by side

Two chapters, the same questions asked of both

Put two Deep Time chapters next to each other — their evidence base, the dating methods behind them, the live debates, and the questions still open.

Open Debate300,000 – 30,000 years ago

Denisovans

A population defined largely by DNA — and what a finger bone can and cannot tell us.

Open full chapter →
Archaeological300,000 – 10,000 years ago

Hunter Gatherers

Mobility, diet, and the social structures that preceded permanent settlement.

Open full chapter →
The evidence base

A handful of physical remains and, unusually, far more genetic than skeletal evidence — including DNA recovered from cave sediment.

Open-air and cave sites, portable and parietal art, burials with grave goods, and the earliest monumental construction.

How we know
MethodWhat it constrains
PalaeogenomicsA finger bone, teeth, and sediment-extracted DNAIdentifies a distinct population and its admixture. It cannot reconstruct anatomy.
PalaeoproteomicsCollagen peptide sequences from fragmentary boneAssigns fragments to a lineage where DNA has degraded. Resolution is coarser than genomics.
Population genetic modellingModern genome panelsEstimates admixture timing and proportion within an assumed demographic model.
MethodWhat it constrains
Radiocarbon datingCharcoal, bone collagen and plant remains in occupation layersDates the material sampled, which may be older than the layer that contains it.
Zooarchaeology and archaeobotanyFaunal assemblages and macro-botanical remainsReconstructs diet and season of occupation. Population size stays an estimate.
Isotopic sourcingObsidian, shell and stone traced to geological sourcesDemonstrates movement of material, not necessarily movement of people.
Where specialists disagree
  • Which Asian fossils are Denisovan?

    Several candidate crania are argued for; assignment without molecular data stays provisional.

  • How many distinct Denisovan populations were there?

    Genomic signals suggest deep internal structure rather than one uniform group.

  • How egalitarian were forager societies?

    Rich burials and monumental labour argue against a single uniform model.

  • What role did foragers play in megafaunal extinctions?

    Human predation and rapid climate change overlap in most regions.

Still open
  • What was their full geographic range?
  • Which archaeological assemblages did they make?
  • How did high-altitude adaptation pass into modern Tibetan populations?
  • How much coastal evidence was lost to postglacial sea-level rise?
  • How were monumental projects organised without permanent hierarchy?
  • What social structures preceded the first villages?