Deep Time · Side by side

Two chapters, the same questions asked of both

Put two Deep Time chapters next to each other — their evidence base, the dating methods behind them, the live debates, and the questions still open.

Consensus2.6 million – 11,700 years ago

Ice Ages

Glacial cycles, sea-level change, and the landscapes early humans actually walked.

Open full chapter →
Archaeological4.2 – 2 million years ago

Australopithecus

Bipedalism before big brains — Lucy, Laetoli, and what the fossils can support.

Open full chapter →
The evidence base

Ice cores, deep-sea sediment cores, glacial landforms, and orbital mechanics calculated independently of the geological record.

Fragmentary hominin fossils, footprint trackways, and the volcanic layers that bracket them in East and southern Africa.

How we know
MethodWhat it constrains
Oxygen isotope stratigraphyForaminifera shells in deep-sea sediment coresProduces a continuous global ice-volume curve. Regional temperature must be inferred separately.
Ice core analysisAnnual layers, trapped air bubbles and dust in polar iceDirectly samples past atmosphere back several hundred thousand years. It does not reach earlier glaciations.
Orbital calculationComputed eccentricity, obliquity and precession cyclesPredicts the pacing independently of any sediment. Amplitude of response still requires feedbacks.
MethodWhat it constrains
Argon–argon dating of volcanic tuffsAsh layers above and below fossil horizonsBrackets a fossil between two dated eruptions. Precision depends on how close those layers are.
Functional morphologyPelvis, femur, foot and vertebral remainsEstablishes locomotor capability. It does not tell us how much time was spent in trees.
Ichnology (trackway analysis)Preserved footprints in dated ashRecords gait directly. Attribution to a specific species is inferred from context.
Where specialists disagree
  • Why did cycles shift from roughly 41,000 to roughly 100,000 years?

    The mid-Pleistocene transition is not fully explained by orbital forcing alone.

  • How abrupt were the warming events within glacial periods?

    Ice core records show rapid shifts whose triggers and ocean-circulation role remain argued.

  • How arboreal were these species?

    Upper-limb anatomy retains climbing features while lower-limb anatomy is committed to walking.

  • Which australopith lineage, if any, leads to Homo?

    Candidates exist; the fossil sample is too sparse to settle descent.

Still open
  • What sets the amplitude of each cycle?
  • How much of the coastline record of early humans is now on drowned shelves?
  • How stable are the feedbacks that ended each glacial phase?
  • What selected for bipedalism in the first place?
  • How many contemporary hominin species were there?
  • How much of the record is missing outside the East African rift, where preservation favours discovery?